Past Bollywood: 2000 Years of Dance in Artwork

Past Bollywood: 2000 Years of Dance in Artwork

Past Bollywood: 2000 Years of Dance in Artwork
Legendary Hen Man Dancer (one among a male-female pair), artist unknown. Wooden, lacquer, gold leaf, glass. Mid to late nineteenth century, Burma. From the Burma Artwork Assortment, Northern Illinois College, Reward of Konrad and Sarah Bekker. From

From 31 March till 10 July in San Francisco, you’ll have an opportunity to see that rarest of issues: an Asian artwork exhibition that acknowledges dance. Dance has been the poor cousin in Western Asian artwork historical past for many years: ignored as content material, unused as context. This wellspring of details about non secular practices and the true values of the cultures being represented has lengthy been glossed over in favor of artwork historic priorities: age, materials, type, measurement, market worth. Whereas artwork historical past and dance historical past work hand-in-hand in Chinese language superior analysis, and whereas the worth of dance is unquestioned in Indian superior analysis, we within the West are solely starting to grasp that the complete which means of dance is required to understand historical and Asian cultures. That full which means does not reside in Western society. As an alternative, we should flip to different cultures for the physique knowledge traditions that we have now misplaced.

The famend Indian scholar of Southeast Asian and Himalayan artwork and tradition Dr. Pratapaditya Pal produced an exhibition and guide in 1997, Dancing to the Flute, which examined older, largely pre-1600, artworks that symbolize dance in India. It stands as a uncommon Asian Artwork historical past exhibition catalogue taking dance in artwork as a topic. Dr. Pal opened the door for artwork historians to start their foray into appreciating the transferring artwork of dance. Now, 26 years later, a trio of American curators have picked up the baton, and supplied up a brand new exhibition, a quantum development in regard to artwork historical past, taking dance as a topic within the West: Past Bollywood: 2,000 Years of Dance in Artwork

Nautch Efficiency with Three Dancers, c. 1863. Albumen Silver Print. From the gathering of Catherine Glynn Benkaim and Barbara Timmer. From

The unique idea for a “dance-in-art” exhibition got here from Laura Weinstein, who’s the Ananda Coomaraswamy Curator of South Asian and Islamic Artwork on the Museum of Fantastic Arts in Boston. She envisioned it as a humanities challenge, in itself an ennobling solution to deal with dance, and regarded it a supply of which means. Finally Weinstein was unable to proceed with the evolving present, and her shut collaborator, Forrest McGill, the chief curator and Wattis curator of South and Southeast Asian Artwork on the Asian Artwork Museum of San Francisco, started creating a extra art-historical present, by no means dropping sight of the unique intent. In time, McGill linked with Ainsley M. Cameron, curator of South Asian Artwork, Islamic Artwork, and Antiquities on the Cincinnati Artwork Museum, and an exhibition was born: Past Bollywood: 2000 Years of Dance in Artwork. Co-produced by the Cincinnati Artwork Museum, the place the present opened in November of final yr, the exhibition, otherwise arrayed, opens in San Francisco on 31 March and runs via 10 July. If you’re wherever round San Francisco, I urge you to go see it.

A part of the general programming contains quick gallery performances and scheduled reside performances by Cambodian, Indonesian, and up to date dance firms. One group I strongly advocate—there’s nothing prefer it wherever—is the corporate of conventional Cambodian dancers lead by Prumsodun Okay. He’s a rigorous exponent of classical dancing and a queer artist queering the custom. They don’t depart from conventional expression; they’re impeccable classical dancers. There’s nothing broad or vulgar about this troupe. They’re beautiful, with a model of their very own identification that’s fully authentic and expressed in essentially the most beautiful and noble kinds. Artists of such confidence, ability and daring are uncommon on this world. I might not miss it.

Prumsodun Okay and firm. Picture courtesy of the Asian Artwork Museum of San Francisco

The essays within the catalogue are well timed, maybe overdue, and refreshing to see. Once I started working with Buddhist monk dancers many years in the past, I observed instantly that sure characters within the pantheon danced, and much more, that sure deities and divine figures all the time danced. But, it was by no means mentioned by artwork historians, even when it was the obvious and central aspect of which means in a portray or mural. So, upon seeing Padam Kaimal’s opening essay “Why Do Yoginis Dance?”, I jumped for pleasure. Ultimately, an artwork historian had featured that query. It’s adopted by the equally mandatory essay by the erudite Forrest McGill, “Dancing in Circles.” Basic elements of Asian dance are highlighted, that join simply with the follow and examine of artwork. This articulation from the artwork historic facet is a welcome open gesture towards dancers who use artwork to grasp, and for the practitioners of the dances depicted. Co-curator McGill brings readability to interdisciplinary ideas.

The Lords of the Cremation Grounds Dancing, Tibet, fifteenth century. Reward of the Donald and Shelly Rubin Basis. From

The steadiness and excellence of this present comes from the top quality of the artwork historic curating and analysis. One other instance of taking the step to reinforce interdisciplinary appreciation is that every of the thematic galleries—Destruction and Creation; Devotion; Subjugation; Glorification; and Celebration—options one paintings remoted for specific focus to indicate how the which means of the exhibition and gallery finds expression within the dance depiction. It acts like a primer for every gallery. That is improbable. The viewer is invited to cease, to ponder on one thing particular, after which proceed to expanded examples. That is a sublime and easy solution to share data.


Creation and Destruction: Dancing Shiva Nataraj
Devotion: Lord Krishna dances with the cowgirls
Subjugation: Tantric deity Hevajra dancing, surrounded by dancing yoginis
Glorification: Dancers entertaining a nobleman
Celebration:  Dancing villagers

There have been different exhibitions that relied on a extra avant-garde dance museology, corresponding to Alexandra Munroe’s Third Thoughts, American Artists Ponder Asia (2009) on the Guggenheim in New York; and Alex Siedlecki’s a number of technologically revolutionary exhibitions on Buddhism and dance on the Museo di Arte e Cultura Orientale in Tuscany, together with Meditation in Movement, Footsteps to the Chic (2019). Danser Sa Vie, Dance and Artwork within the twentieth and twenty first Centuries (2012), on the Centre Pompidou in Paris, was a complicated and exquisite integration of dance and tremendous artwork, understanding each as mutually influencing and very important currents of tradition. It was avant-garde in multimedia assemble and idea, taking the mutual affect of dance and artwork as the topic. The Pompidou Centre exhibition launched a brand new strategy to bop museology.

A multimedia archival celebration was the exhibition Merce Cunningham: Frequent Time (2017), a curated two-museum present highlighting the artwork components of Cunningham’s work, from movies to set items. Cunningham famously labored with distinguished up to date artists. This avant-garde strategy to curating dance-in-art and dance-as-art was created by the Museum of Modern Artwork in Chicago, in collaboration with The Walker Artwork Heart in Minneapolis. There’s a beautiful catalogue of that exhibition out there. The purpose right here in San Francisco is to strategy the topic of dance in artwork, coming from the self-discipline of Asian artwork historical past. It succeeds, being such a tremendous instance of what it’s.

The exhibition options dance depictions of Hindu, Buddhist, Muslim, and tribal societies. Artwork historical past, like dance historical past, finds many connections in tantra of all stripes, Hindu and Buddhist, lay and robed, inasmuch because the theme of non-duality itself defies sectarianism. As soon as once more, these curators enable the artwork to do the educating, and the choice is classy. Dancing deities, dancing animals, dancing women; masked dance, social dance, powers of the universe dancing: Shiva Nataraj, performing the cosmic dance of creation and destruction, frozen in motion as a bronze.

The Buddhist Deity Vajravarahi. Bronze, gilding, inlaid turquoise. Tibet, 14th century. From

As a result of the artwork examples are so good—and by that particularly, I imply that not solely dance as an art-created image is obtainable, however dance itself as a sequence of steps and strikes and positions—the exhibition’s absence of any actual dance analysis is apparent to me. There are tremendous students, corresponding to Alessandra Iyer, a specialist within the sculpture and dance of Java, who actually know the best way to interpret artwork from the perspective of historic dance follow. She would have introduced one other dimension of understanding, denied to most of us.

Ohio, the place this present originated, has a tremendous establishment of dance analysis: the Graduate College of Dance at Ohio State College, one the perfect wherever. These sources might have been folded into the dance-themed exhibition with not an excessive amount of bother, offering there’s a mutually supportive collaboration. Seeing how thoughtfully—and clearly—this exhibition is about out, I can solely think about how good it will be to collaborate with dance researchers, multiplying the views and amplifying the which means. The dance world would welcome it.

Krisna Overcoming Kaliya, the Serpent. Copper alloy, Tamil Nadu, India, late tenth century. Mr. and Mrs. John D. Rockefeller Third Assortment, Asia Society, New York. From

The reality is, superior analysis in dance research is far much less frequent than artwork historical past. Dance researchers are one thing to go looking out, and dance analysis advantages from the affiliation with tremendous artwork scholarship and conservation. With out query, it was the Asian artwork world that first appreciated the dances of Buddhist monks and Newar monks . . . not the dance world. It was due to a collaboration with artwork conservation efforts that dance preservation grew to become launched and higher identified. Might the fruitful collaboration of dance analysis and artwork analysis proceed in lots of kinds.

I stay up for seeing two up to date works of video artwork by Singaporean artist Sarah Choo Jing. One, a three-panel panorama video, is titled Artwork of the Rehearsal. The opposite is Artwork of the Rehearsal: Portrait Collection. On the Asian Artwork Museum of San Francisco, Portrait Collection can be displayed initially of the exhibition. Upon getting into, the very first thing one encounters is three dancers, reflecting the Chinese language, Malay, and Indian threads of the artist’s cultural identification. Every of them is getting ready to carry out, readying costumes and making use of make-up, one thing without delay intimate, routine, and ritualistic. Then one makes their approach via all the exhibition of 120 artworks, pictures, movies, posters, sculptures, reduction work, and eventually on the finish, the big three-panel video is offered as a last abiding picture. It exhibits an imagined Singapore cityscape during which the dancers seem and disappear and dance, revealing layers of tradition and ethnicity. The exhibition concludes with a lingering query in regards to the elusive nature of dance and its skill to hold advanced identities. This residing and up to date solution to body the present is pleasant, and even humble earlier than the good thriller of dance.

Dancing Ganesh, copper alloy. Karnataka, India, sixteenth century. From

Artwork exhibitions that includes Buddhist dance in artwork are usually not frequent. This present has unimaginable Buddhist dance artwork from Burma, Cambodia, India, Mongolia, Nepal, Sri Lanka, Thailand, and Tibet. It grandly reveals entire milieus of motion and design, of which Buddhism, Buddhist artwork, and Buddhist dance, have been an element. Underlying connections with broader tradition and esoteric follow develop into seen on this illuminating exhibition, the place the key phrase is “dance.”  Hats off to the curators and the funders, together with the Nationwide Endowment of the Humanities, which supported this challenge from their program Democracy Calls for Knowledge, and the Nationwide Endowment for the Arts. Please—fund extra tasks that increase our idea of data by higher understanding of the dances of Asia and the world.

Lastly, seminal credit score goes to Laura Weinstein, who obtained this entire endeavor transferring, desiring to discover in artwork, a easy however profound idea: dance has which means. What’s it?

Past Bollywood, 2000 Years of Dance in Arts
Asian Artwork Museum of San Francisco
March 31 – July 10, 2023
200 Larkin St
San Francisco 94102

See extra

Coming Quickly | Past Bollywood: 2000 Years of Dance in Artwork (Asian Artwork Museum)
Core of Tradition

Associated options from BDG

Buddhist Opera?
Dance and Museums, Celebrating Core of Tradition at 20
Meditation in Movement, Footsteps to the Chic

Extra from Historical Dances by Joseph Houseal

Leave a Reply